Strange to Say Subscribe
A long cast-iron radiator under tall open windows with white shutters, in the pink front bedroom of a rowhouse on T Street, Washington, photographed in 2018.

Case file 04

Old American Houses Were Designed to Fight a Disease

The story says old radiators were made big for the 1918 flu. The oldest paper trail we found leads to 1910, and to the tuberculosis fresh-air craze that shaped the American house.

  • Film, 9 min 40 s
  • 35 sources
  • Re-checked on

Play the film9:40Subscribe

Washington, photo 2018Historic American Buildings Survey, 2018. Library of Congress, Prints & Photographs Division, HABS DC-890-25 (CT) (public domain)

The film plays from YouTube (youtube-nocookie.com) only when you press play.

The case in brief

Walk into an old apartment in winter and you will often find a cast-iron radiator under the window, far bigger than the room seems to need. The story says it was made that big in 1918, so a room could be heated with the windows wide open during the flu. In 2020, during another pandemic, that story spread again.

This case file follows the paper trail. In 1918 we found no document that sizes a single radiator for the flu. The Army Surgeon General's open-window rule of September 1918 was real, but the national tuberculosis association reprinted it as advice it had been giving for years. The oldest paper trail we found leads to a heating trade paper of 14 May 1910, which reported a German rule: thirty per cent more radiator surface for rooms opened to the outside air at night.

Behind it stood tuberculosis, which killed 38,820 people in 1900 in the American states that kept death records, and a fresh-air campaign that built sleeping porches onto houses and painted the walls inside them. Then the file asks whether any of it worked.

In this file: Exhibits, Where it stands, Transcript, Sources and credits

Exhibits

5 frames from the film. Select one to see it at full size.

Page 5 of the Bulletin of the National Tuberculosis Association, October 1918: Surgeon General Issues Health Rules, a list of twelve rules, with rule 6, Open the windows, always at home at night, underlined in red pencil.Open exhibit A at full size

Exhibit AIn the film at 0:56

Exhibit one: the 1918 rules

In September 1918 the Army's Surgeon General issued rules for avoiding the flu. One of them reads: “Open the windows: always at home at night.” This copy ran in the October 1918 bulletin of the national tuberculosis association, which reprinted the rules “in relation to the anti-tuberculosis campaign”. To that association, open windows were not new advice. In 1918 we found no document that sizes a single radiator for the flu.

Source: Bulletin of the National Tuberculosis Association, vol. 5 no. 1, October 1918, page 5, “Surgeon General Issues Health Rules” (claim HEAT-01). The sources are under “The radiator story and the 1910 paper trail” below

Card from the film: 38,820 deaths from tuberculosis in 1900, in the states that kept death records, beside the leading causes of death in 1900, pneumonia and influenza first and tuberculosis second, and the years tuberculosis ranked first, 1902, 1903, 1905, 1906, 1908 and 1909, marked in red.Open exhibit B at full size

Exhibit BIn the film at 1:59

The disease behind the advice

In 1900, in the American states that kept death records, tuberculosis killed 38,820 people, 11.3 per cent of all deaths. That year it was the second-biggest killer, just behind pneumonia and influenza; it ranked first in 1902, 1903, 1905, 1906, 1908 and 1909. A household-science textbook of 1905 put it at one tenth of all deaths in the country. There was no cure, only a belief that fresh air, rest and food might let the body heal itself.

Source: Drawn in code for this film from CDC/NCHS, Leading Causes of Death, 1900 to 1998, death-registration states (claims HEALTH-01 and HEALTH-04). The sources are under “Tuberculosis and the fresh-air cure” below

Page 30 of Fresh Air and How to Use It, 1912: a photograph of a bedroom where a white canvas window tent covers the head of a bed pushed against the window, with the sleeper's face showing through a small pane in the tent.Open exhibit C at full size

Exhibit CIn the film at 4:10

Exhibit two: the window tent

In 1912 the national tuberculosis association published a manual, Fresh Air and How to Use It, for healthy families as well as the sick. Its preface says fresh air, “emphasized first as an agent of cure”, was now valued “as a mode of prevention”. It shows how to add a sleeping porch to an ordinary house, and for families without one it offers the window tent: a canvas hood fitted to an open window, first devised for patients and “now used by many healthy persons” in winter.

Source: Thomas Spees Carrington, Fresh Air and How to Use It (New York: National Association for the Study and Prevention of Tuberculosis, 1912), page 30 (claims HOUSE-01 and HOUSE-02). The sources are under “The fresh-air house: porches, walls, floors and bathrooms” below

Page 150 of Domestic Engineering, 14 May 1910, with the words the craze for sleeping in rooms with the heat off and windows open is spreading so rapidly underlined in red pencil.Open exhibit D at full size

Exhibit DIn the film at 4:53

Exhibit three: the 1910 paper trail

On 14 May 1910 the heating engineer Edward Richmond Pierce wrote in the Chicago trade paper Domestic Engineering that “the craze for sleeping in rooms with the heat off and windows open is spreading so rapidly”. He reported a German rule: thirty per cent more radiator surface for rooms heated by day and opened to the outside air at night. For people who shut off the heat at night and leave a window open, he advised twenty to forty per cent more radiator in that room. That is the big radiator, in print, eight years before the flu. That it was standard American practice is unverified.

Source: Edward Richmond Pierce, Domestic Engineering vol. 51 no. 7, 14 May 1910, pages 149 and 150, reprinted in his manual of 1911, pages 46 to 48 (claim HEAT-01). The sources are under “The radiator story and the 1910 paper trail” below

Timeline card from the film: about 1900, Saranac Lake porches; 14 May 1910, Pierce in the trade paper Domestic Engineering, reprinted as his manual in 1911; 1912, Fresh Air and How to Use It; September 1918, the Surgeon General's rules, circled in red; 2007, Dan Holohan ties the radiator to tuberculosis and the open-window craze; and in red, 2020, retellings move it to 1918, with a red arrow from 2020 back to 1918.Open exhibit E at full size

Exhibit EIn the film at 5:31

The paper trail, in order

Around 1900, patients at Saranac Lake began sleeping on porches in winter. In 1910 Pierce's article ran in Domestic Engineering, and in 1912 the tuberculosis association published Fresh Air and How to Use It. The Surgeon General's rules came in September 1918. The heating writer most associated with the story, Dan Holohan, first told it in 2007 as part of the open-window craze and tuberculosis; his retellings in 2020 moved it to 1918.

Source: Drawn in code for this film from claims HOUSE-01, HOUSE-02 and HEAT-01. The sources are under “The radiator story and the 1910 paper trail” and “The fresh-air house: porches, walls, floors and bathrooms” below

Status

Where it stands (as of November 8, 2026)

The oldest paper trail we found for the big radiator is the heating trade paper Domestic Engineering of 14 May 1910; we found no 1918 document that sizes a radiator for the flu. Tuberculosis is not history everywhere: the WHO fact sheet of 24 March 2026 counts about 1.23 million deaths from it in 2024, more than any other single infectious disease.

Re-checked on

Transcript

The full narration, 1,390 words

0:00The story everyone tells

Walk into an old apartment in winter and you will often find it: a cast-iron radiator under the window, far bigger than the room seems to need. And if you ask why it is so big, there is a story you will probably hear. In 1918, the story goes, a pandemic flu swept the world. Doctors said fresh air would help, so engineers sized radiators to heat a room with the windows wide open. In 2020, during another pandemic, that story spread again.

It is a good story. It makes sense of an odd object, and it ties your living room to history. But a good story is not evidence. So we did what this channel always does. We went looking for the paper trail.

0:49Exhibit one: 1918

If radiators were sized for the flu, the first place to look is 1918 itself. In September 1918 the Army's Surgeon General issued rules for avoiding the flu. One of them reads: "Open the windows: always at home at night."

So the advice was real. But look at where this copy was printed. It appears in the bulletin of the national tuberculosis association, which reprinted the rules, in its own words, in relation to its campaign against tuberculosis. Why would a tuberculosis association print flu advice? Because to that association, "open the windows" was not new. It was their own advice, and they had been giving it for years. And in 1918 we found no document that sizes a single radiator for the flu.

1:40The disease behind the advice

To see why, we have to go back to a disease that most of us now think of as history. In 1882 a German doctor, Robert Koch, identified the germ that causes tuberculosis. Announcing it, he said that one in every seven human beings died of the disease. In 1900, in the American states that kept death records, tuberculosis killed 38,820 people in a single year. That year it was the second-biggest killer, just behind pneumonia and influenza. In most years of the next decade, it was the first. A household-science textbook of 1905 put it simply: tuberculosis was responsible for one tenth of all deaths in the country.

There was no cure. There was only a belief: that fresh air, rest and food might let the body heal itself. At a sanatorium, that belief became a daily routine: hours of bed rest in the open air, in all weather, wrapped in blankets on a porch or in a hut. Film from a Pennsylvania sanatorium in 1926 shows children playing in the snow below its porches. By 1904 America had 115 sanatoriums, with about 8,000 beds. In 1907, a woman in Delaware named Emily Bissell sold the first Christmas Seals to keep one of them open.

3:14Exhibit two: the sleeping porch

The most famous of those places was in the Adirondack mountains of New York, at Saranac Lake. Around 1900, patients there began sleeping outdoors, on porches, in winter. After that, the record says, no cottage was built without direct access to a porch.

Then the idea left the hospital. Schools tried it first. In Rochester, New York, in 1912, children took their rest period in an open-air classroom, bundled up against the cold. In 1912 the national tuberculosis association published a manual called "Fresh Air and How to Use It". It was not written only for the sick. It was written for healthy families. Its preface says fresh air had been valued first as a cure, and was now valued as a way to prevent the disease. It shows how to add a sleeping porch to an ordinary house. And for families without one, it offers the window tent: a canvas hood fitted to an open window, so a healthy person could sleep with their head outside all winter. By 1915 a Seattle builders' guide said at least one sleeping porch was usually included in the modern house. Not every one was medical. Some were simply cooler on a summer night.

4:34Exhibit three: the 1910 paper trail

So now we had a craze for sleeping with the windows open, years before the flu. And a craze like that has a cost. Someone has to heat those rooms.

Strange to say, the oldest paper trail we found for the big radiator does not lead to 1918. It leads to 1910, and to an article in a heating trade paper. Its author worried about a new problem for heating engineers: "the craze for sleeping in rooms with the heat off and windows open is spreading so rapidly." And he reported a German rule: add thirty per cent more radiator surface to rooms that are heated by day and opened to the outside air at night. And his own advice, for people who shut off the heat at night and leave a window open: twenty to forty per cent more radiator in that room. That is the big radiator, in print, eight years before the flu.

Even the heating writer most associated with the story, Dan Holohan, first told it in 2007 as part of the open-window craze and tuberculosis. Later retellings moved it to 1918. The flu did not start the open-window habit. It met a habit that tuberculosis had already built into the house.

5:52The house: walls, floors and bathrooms

And once you know what to look for, the radiator is not alone. The same 1912 manual tells families how to build a room that dust cannot hide in. Walls should be painted, not papered. No mouldings or cornices to catch the dust. And the corners where walls meet the ceiling should be rounded.

Household textbooks of the time warned that carpets, heavy curtains and chairs fringed to the floor stored dust. Out they went. In their place, a new floor. In 1918 the maker of linoleum told buyers that the linseed oil in its product was poisonous to germs.

The bathroom changed too: white tile, white porcelain, and pipes left in the open where they could be watched and cleaned. But here the trail goes back even further. The white bathroom began with an older fear, of sewer gas, before germs were understood. Tuberculosis took that idea over and made it stricter. In the 1870s and 1880s, many doctors believed disease travelled through bad air, and that gas seeping from drains could poison a family in its sleep. Fixtures boxed in wood, they warned, soon turned foul. So the pipes came out where you could see them. And the built-in cupboards of the period were sold mostly to save space, with hygiene as a second selling point. Not every feature was about disease.

7:22The verdict: did any of it work?

Before 1933, the US death figures in the film's charts come only from the states that kept full death records.

So, was the big radiator built for the 1918 flu? The record we found says no. Its paper trail starts in 1910, in the fresh-air years that tuberculosis began. The flu revived the advice. It did not invent it.

But there is one more question in this file. Did any of it work? By 1943, the American death rate from tuberculosis had fallen by about four fifths since 1900. One caution about that line: before 1933, the figures come only from the states that kept full death records, so the early years are a large sample, not the whole country. That was before the first effective drug. Streptomycin was announced in 1944. With it, the fall sped up again.

Fresh air was never shown to cure the disease. Economists who studied the campaign's measures from 1900 to 1917 found they explain only a small part of the decline. Better food, better housing and less crowding probably did more. The porches and the painted walls were the belief, built in wood and iron.

8:37Closing: what old houses still show

Tuberculosis is not history everywhere. In 2024 it killed about 1.23 million people, more than any other single infectious disease.

And the fear left one more mark. In 1923 the architect Le Corbusier called the old house "an old coach full of tuberculosis", and praised the sun parlours that America had built to fight the disease. Historians still argue how much tuberculosis shaped modern architecture. But the clean white room many of us live in has at least one ancestor in a sanatorium.

In many old buildings the evidence is still there: a porch nobody sleeps on, a corner with no moulding, and under the window, a radiator built for a room with the window open. It was not built for a flu. It was built for a fear that came first.

Sources and credits

Every claim in the film has a source, and every photograph and document is credited. 35 sources, grouped by the part of the story they support, then the credits for every image and sound in the film, with the license for the 3 images used under Creative Commons.

Sources

The radiator story and the 1910 paper trail

Tuberculosis and the fresh-air cure

The fresh-air house: porches, walls, floors and bathrooms

Tuberculosis and modern architecture

Credits

Photographs and film

Documents and maps

Artwork and graphics

Music

  • Music generated with ElevenLabs Music

Narration

  • Narration voice generated with ElevenLabs (voice: Peter)

Sound effects

  • Sound effects generated with ElevenLabs sound effects

Cards, maps and charts

  • Drawn in code for this film from the sourced records: the case-file cards, labels and tabs, the death-count card, the German-rule radiator diagram, the paper-trail timeline and the tuberculosis charts. The documents, photographs and film cut into them are real and credited above. No picture in the film is AI-generated.